How to Make an Old Baseball Glove Look New

Are you looking for a way to make your old baseball glove look new again? If so, then you’ve come to the right place. A baseball glove is a cherished item for any player. Over time, they can become worn and stained. Baseball gloves can last many seasons with proper care. 

How to Make an Old Baseball Glove Look New

If you have an old baseball glove that you would like to make look new again, follow these simple steps that are discussed in this article. In this blog post, we will be teaching you how to make an old baseball glove look new. So, without further ado, let’s get started!

How Do You Restore Batting Gloves?

The first step in restoring an old batting glove is to clean it. Before beginning the restoration process, you will want to remove any dirt and debris from your glove. To do so, simply use a mild detergent mixed with warm water and gently scrub the leather surfaces of your glove. 

Make sure that you avoid getting the inside of the glove too wet, as this could cause the leather to shrink or even crack. Once you have finished cleaning, rinse off the glove and allow it to air dry completely. Once your glove is clean, you will want to condition it with a quality leather conditioner. Leather conditioners help keep the leather of your glove soft and supple. 

When applying the conditioner, you will want to make sure that you are being generous with it. Apply the leather conditioner in small circular motions to evenly coat your glove and allow it to fully absorb the product. Once your glove is coated, buff the excess away with a clean cloth and let it dry completely before use.

10 Methods How to Make an Old Baseball Glove Look New

1. Wipe down the Glove with a Damp Cloth:

Before you start applying any type of cleaning product, use a damp cloth to wipe down the glove. This will help remove dirt and dust that can build up over time. Although this won’t make the glove look brand new, it will help prepare it for additional cleaning and conditioning. Make sure to use a gentle cloth and minimal water to avoid damaging the glove.

2. Use an Eraser or Brush:

If the glove is still dirty after wiping it down with a damp cloth, try using a pencil eraser or soft brush to remove any remaining dirt and debris. If you are using a brush, be sure to move in the same direction as the grain of the leather. This will help get rid of any tough stains that are stuck on the glove. However, be gentle and use minimal pressure to avoid damaging the leather.

Using a Pencil Eraser

3. Apply Leather Cleaner:

Once the glove is free of dirt and dust, you can apply a leather cleaner to help keep it in good condition. Make sure to follow the instructions on the product carefully. Additionally, test the cleaner on a small, inconspicuous area of the glove before applying it to the rest. Try to find a product that is specifically designed for baseball gloves to ensure the best results.

4. Condition the Glove:

After cleaning, you’ll want to condition the glove with a good quality leather conditioner or cream. This will help keep it soft and supple while also helping protect it from damage over time. You may also want to invest in a leather conditioner specifically made for baseball gloves. Again, be sure to test the product on a small area of the glove before applying it to the entire surface. Make sure to use gentle strokes and avoid rubbing too hard.

5. Spot Treat Stains:

If there are any stubborn stains on your glove, try using a damp cloth and some mild soap to spot-treat them. You may need to repeat this step several times before all of the stains come out. However, make sure not to scrub too hard, as this can damage the leather. If the stains are still not coming out, consider taking the glove to a leather professional for additional cleaning.

6. Use a Toothbrush:

If the glove is still looking dirty, try using an old toothbrush to scrub any hard-to-reach crevices and get rid of any remaining dirt or grime. While you’re at it, use a leather cleaner to help clean any other areas of the glove. Although this won’t make the glove look brand new, it will help keep it in good condition and extend its lifespan.

Try Using an Old Toothbrush

7. Lubricate the Stitching:

Make sure you’re lubricating the stitching on your glove regularly. This will help prevent it from becoming brittle and breaking down over time. However, be sure to use a lubricant that is specifically designed for leather and avoid any petroleum-based products. Additionally, make sure you’re using minimal lubricant, as too much can damage the leather. Try to find a leather lubricant specially made for baseball gloves for the best results.

8. Add Glove Wrap:

To give your glove extra protection against wear and tear, consider adding some glove wrap around the fingers, thumb, and wrist area. This will help keep it in good condition for longer. Make sure to use a wrap that is specifically designed for baseball gloves, as this will offer the best protection. Additionally, be sure to follow the instructions on the packaging carefully.

9. Store Properly:

Always make sure to store your baseball glove properly when you’re not using it. This will help keep it from becoming warped and misshapen over time. However, avoid storing your glove in direct sunlight or a humid area, as this can cause the leather to dry out and crack. Additionally, don’t store your glove near any chemicals, as this can damage it. If you have a large glove, consider investing in a special storage bag to keep it in.

10. Use a Batting Glove:

To give your glove extra protection when playing, consider wearing a batting glove underneath the glove. This will help reduce the wear and tear on your baseball glove so that it looks new for longer. If you’re playing in a particularly hot climate, consider investing in a batting glove made with cooling technology. 

consider wearing a batting glove

Additionally, make sure to wash and dry the batting glove after each use. Following these steps will help keep your baseball glove looking new for longer and ensure that it lasts a long time. With proper care and maintenance, your glove will perform at its best for many seasons to come.

Things to Consider While Making an Old Baseball Glove Look New

1. Clean the Glove:

Make sure you’re regularly cleaning your glove with a damp cloth and mild soap to remove any dirt or debris that may have accumulated over time.

2. Condition the Leather:

To help keep the leather from cracking and becoming brittle, you should condition your glove with a good quality leather conditioner or petroleum jelly on a regular basis. Although leather conditioners are typically more expensive, they’re great for protecting the leather and making it look new.

3. Replace the Laces:

Over time, laces can become frayed and weak, so it’s important to replace them for strength and durability. If your glove doesn’t have laces, you can buy a kit that includes replacement laces and tools for easy installation.

4. Re-Stuff the Glove:

Old stuffing can break down over time and make it more difficult to catch a ball with your glove, so replacing it is important.

5. Oil Your Glove:

Oiling your glove will help prevent any further damage to the leather and extend its life. Try to use an oil that is specifically made for baseball gloves.

Damage to the Leather

6. Re-Grip the Glove:

Re-gripping your glove will allow you to maintain a better grip on your glove and the ball. While re-gripping, make sure you use a leather preservative to help prevent any more wear and tear.

7. Store Your Glove Properly:

Storing your glove properly after each use is important for maintaining its condition over time. Make sure to store it in a well-ventilated bag away from any direct sunlight or heat sources.

8. Have It Professionally Relaced:

If all else fails, you can always have an expert replace your glove with new laces for optimal performance and durability.  This may be more expensive than other options, but it’s worth it if you want the best results possible for your glove.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Oil My Baseball Glove?

Yes. Many players oil their baseball gloves as a preventative measure against sweat and dirt getting inside the glove and causing discomfort. It is also common to oil the glove when it is first received so that the leather is protected from rubbing against other objects.

What Softens a Baseball Glove?

There are a few common materials that are used to soften baseball gloves, including natural and synthetic fibers, water, and glycerin. Natural fibers, such as cotton, are often considered the softest and most comfortable gloves, while synthetic fibers, such as polyester, are usually harder and more durable. Water is a common softening agent for baseball gloves because it helps to dissolve the hard polymer shell of the glove and make it more pliable. Glycerin is also frequently used to soften baseball gloves because it helps to prevent the glove from sticking to the hand.

Can You Use Baby Oil on a Baseball Glove?

Baby oil is a natural oil that is used to moisturize and protect the skin. It is not recommended to use baby oil on a baseball glove because it may cause the glove to become wet and sticky, which could lead to poor grip and performance. Instead, use a moisturizer or a cream designed specifically for baseball gloves.

Is a Baseball Glove Ruined if It Gets Wet?

No, a baseball glove is not ruined if it gets wet. In fact, a wet glove can actually help improve your batting skills. When your glove is wet, the moisture on your hand helps to distribute the weight of the bat more evenly, which makes it easier to hit the ball. Additionally, a wet glove can reduce the amount of air friction that is created when you hit the ball, which makes it less likely that the ball will be deflected or caught by the fielder.


If you want to make your old baseball glove look new again, follow these easy steps. With a little bit of elbow grease and the right materials, you can clean and condition your glove, so it looks just like it did when you first got it. 

Thanks for reading our blog post on how to make an old baseball glove look new! We hope you found it helpful and informative.

Photo of author

Matt Clark

Hi, this is Matt, and I am a leathercraft hobbyist. I have been working with leather for quite a bit of time. When I was a teenager, my father taught me the basics of leathercraft. Along the way I have learned a lot of things about leather work leather items, restoring leather, and creating leather accessories. I started this blog to share my knowledge of leatherworking with others and help people learn about this amazing craft. I also wanted to create a community of like-minded people who could share ideas and support each other in their leatherworking journey.

Leave a Comment